Issue – the ideal answer.
|
Judaism
|
Other religions
|
Law transmitted by God Himself not by an agent
|
Jewish people actually heard transmission of Torah from God Himself
|
Transmitted by a single human being to others
|
Transmission of law witnessed by millions people
|
The giving of the Torah by God Himself at mount Sinai was witnessed by over 3 million people. Of which 600,000 Jewish men between the age of 20 to 60 witnessed the event.
|
Witnessed by one individual or several individuals
|
Transmitted by a person who spoke directly to God face to face
|
Moshe Rabbeinu / Moses Our Teacher spoke to God face to face like a person would speak to another person, while he was completely awake and lucid.
|
Transmitted by a person who had a dream
|
Law conceived by God
|
God created the Torah and then created the world. The law is his law.
|
Group of people conceived law
|
God did open miraculous kindness for an entire nation
|
God sends plagues upon Egyptians and brings Jewish people out of Egypt in front of all the world.
|
Did not do miracles for entire nation.
|
Law is based upon principles that cannot be changed by man
|
God gave to Torah is written Torah and the Oral Torah. All laws must conform to what is written in the Oral Torah. (Which is now the Talmud)
|
People have discretion to change laws according to their whim
|
God changes nature for a entire nation
|
God sends 10 plagues upon Egypt to punish Egyptians for pain they caused the Jews.
|
Does things for individuals
|
God punishes nations that hurt entire nation
|
God sends 10 plagues upon Egypt because they caused suffering to the Jewish nation.
|
Does things for individuals
|
God helps entire nation to be victorious in war
|
God helps Jewish nation to be victorious over nations much mightier than them in the wilderness of Sinai
|
Win by force. (Of course with the will of G-d)
|
Explanation of God’s features makes logical sense
|
God is not physical nor spiritual. He is the essence of existence. Has no deficiencies or weaknesses. He is Perfect. He is One. He is Unlimited. He is everywhere.
|
Their concept of “gods” are illogical. It can be an animal or a man (either dead or alive) or an object – “that is dead, eventually dies or decays or can be destroyed. If a “god” dies, or is dead, decays or can be destroyed it has a weakness and logically cannot be the real god. Assumes G-d changes his mind after taking a well thought out decision – if G-d is perfect he wouldn’t change his mind.
|
Is Truth
|
Allows and encourages questions to arrive at the truth. Truth is not afraid of questions.
|
Use manipulative tactics to avoid truth or threats because their doctrine cannot stand up to the test of truth. Punish people who deny their doctrine.
|
Has detailed laws that deal with all situations.
|
Has specific and detailed laws that are either treated directly or can be derived from the Talmud.
|
Have vague laws based on general foundations of the religion. No specific details of cases.
|
Detailed Laws are based upon Torah’s Laws
|
Detailed laws that correspond directly with Torah Laws (ie, five books of Moses).
|
Have vague laws many of which have nothing to do with the Torah’s commandments or are against the Torah’s commandments ie, – “Do not make an image of G-d.”
|
Giving of law witnessed by trustworthy people
|
The Jews were on the level of righteousness so high that they attained prophecy when they received the Torah.
|
Was witnessed by harlots, immoral people or killers.
|
Transmitted by righteous people
|
Moshe Rabbeinu who transmitted the Torah was so righteous he was able to speak with God directly
|
Transmitted by killers and sinners “if they could kill they could lie also
|
Based upon logic, not miracles
|
Hash-m did thousands of miracles for the Jewish nation – “ten plagues, manna, splitting of the sea of reeds, etc. But belief in Torah is not based on miracles. It is based upon historical fact, G-d’s communication with the Jewish people, common sense and logic. See Rambam “ Laws of Mashiach / Messiah. Laws of Kings – chapter 11“
|
Believe because one or more people were subject to or did miracles. Because of the existence of freedom of choice even wicked people can actually do “miracles” – ie, voodoo, black magic. Thus doing Miracles is not a proof of veracity.
|
Allows truths to be questioned and is open to questions – open minded to allow questions to arrive at the truth
|
Questions will surely encouraged – Anyone who learns Gemara or Talmud realizes how open the Torah is to questions
|
Religions censor people and works that are contrary to their beliefs in order that they do not discover the truth. They hide the truth or deny questions and provide roundabout answers. They Give very vague verses from the “Bible” to show their veracity – yet these verses are misinterpreted by them, because they did not receive the Oral Torah that explains exactly what the verse means.
|
Meaningful and well thought out laws, rituals and customs
|
Rituals are pleasant like having meals with the family on Shabbat and holidays. Prayer.
|
Have unusual rituals and laws sometimes subjecting followers to flagellate themselves, torturing themselves, throwing people into fire. They burn wives of upon death of husband. Some Religion leaders do not procreate – if all of the members of the religion would become leaders their would be no members of the religion after that generation.
|
Believe that God is an entity that is not physical or spiritual. It is not logical to say that God is physical or spiritual, because anything that is physical or spiritual can be created or destroyed. Anything that can be created or destroyed cannot be God.
|
Hash-m is not physical nor spiritual. He is the Essence of perfection and goodness.
|
Some propose God is physical. They may say he is a man, an object, or an animal. they attribute godly attributes to a mound of flesh Or to an inanimate a pile of stones or a statue. All these have the weakness “they can be destroyed. Therefore they cannot be the true god.
|
Common people who follow the religion are righteous.
|
The basic rule for the Jews is to love one’s fellow like one’s self. Observant Jews do many and exemplary acts of kindness.
|
Though many are righteous, many times in history the masses of people were killers and instigators in that they actively participated in in pogroms, crusades, blood-libels, aiding the Nazis, terrorism and anti-Semitic campaigns.
|
Top leaders are exemplary righteous people
|
Top leaders are exemplary in morality, in kindness and in following the laws of the Torah.
|
Many scandals are surfacing against top leaders – stealing, killing, immorality, etc. Gurus make up their own set of laws ie – it’s OK to steal if the Guru gains money from it.
|
Foundations of the beliefs of the ideology are logical
|
Foundations are based upon solid evidence and logic (and see 13 principles of faith of the Rambam)
|
Believe because you have to believe (they force people to believe because their claims make are irrational like their “god” is a dead man.) To quell the masses they say it is improper to ask questions or to just believe on faith. No sane person would by a car on “faith” that it has an engine. Subscribing to a religion – that one’s life in heaven depends upon – should be subject to at least the same scrutiny.
|
Foundations of Religion are consistent with the Document of the Law
|
Foundations of Torah is that G-d is One, He is Perfect, He is not Physical. It says in the Torah “You shall not make any image that is on earth or in the Heavens” – The second of 10 commandments.
|
Their god is a physical entity or a physical entity represents their g-d which is explicitly forbidden in the 5 Books of Moses.
|
All people are treated with sensitivity
|
Each man must be respected because he was created in the image of Hash-m. Never killed innocent people on basis of the Torah.
|
Killed millions of innocent people in the name of “God” and their religion – historically and currently condone killing of innocent people who through terrorism, pogroms, violence, etc.
|
Are in sync with morality and common sense
|
Each person should be treated with respect and dignity.
|
Their law says “don’t kill.” Yet in actuality religions were at times one of the greatest terror organizations. Historically and currently condone killing of innocent people through terrorism, pogroms, violence, holy wars, holocaust, genocide, intifada, etc.
|
Number of witnesses to Origin of Religion
|
Millions of Jewish People “600,000 men witnessed and heard G-d’s voice at Sinai
|
Two harlots, person who had a dream, guru that got a divine message
|
Number of Adherents
|
Millions
|
Hundreds of Millions “number of adherents is not a testimony to the truth“ see below (If a million people say 1 + 1 = 3 and one person says 1 + 1 = 2. Who is right? The million people or the one person?) Easier to follow ones desires than to control ones desires. There was a point in time that a majority of the world believed the world was flat. Does that mean that the world was flat at that time point in time?
|
Claims to have millions of witnesses to transmission of the law – and has proof
|
Millions of Jewish people saw and heard Hashem – G-d giving the Torah.
|
Don’t make any claims that millions of people witnessed giving or Re-transmission of the law
|
Claims G-d did not – “change his mind”
|
Hash-m is perfect. His knowledge is perfect. He knows the past and the future. He does not change his mind.
|
Say G-d changes his mind.
|
G-d did not change his people
|
Hash-m chose only the Jewish people to be the Chosen nation and they remain to be his Chosen nation. He never changed them with another nation.
There are proofs of this in Torah and according to logic. If someone employs a thousand people. If he decides to fire them he sends them pink slips. “Pink slips” or another declaration never was made that Hash-m rescinded his covenant with them. When one introduces a product they do much publicity if they wish to recall it they also use much publicity. It is an eternal covenant. Hashem forgave the Jews for any sins that they did. Mishkan Haedut “ the Mishkan is a testimony to the fact that Hashem forgave us for the sin of the Golden Calf.
|
Say G-d changed his people with another people.
|
The Law is Divine
|
The Torah is Divine. How do we know the Torah is Divine? Millions of witnesses heard transmission of law from Hash-m himself at Mount Sinai.
|
Law made up by men.
|
G-d did not change the original nation that he chose.
|
G-d does not change his mind. He has perfect knowledge and knows the future. He would not select a nation and then “change his mind.” The Jews were Hash-m’s chosen people and remain his chosen people and will remain to be his chosen people forever.
|
Other religions say G-d changed the original nation that he chose. This is the basis for their religion’s existence.
|
Treat non-members of the religion in respectful manner.
|
Even the most lowly of people “Bilaam” – the gentile prophet who was unable to answer the rebuke of his talking donkey – who wished to curse the Jews was spared embarrassment. Hash-m his donkey killed so that people wouldn’t point to the donkey saying “look that is the donkey that Bilaam couldn’t answer back” and embarrass Bilaam.
|
Vilify Jews and create hatred among their people of Jews. Teach children to Hate Jews from an early age – even in schools. Create heros out of those who commit violence against Jews. Call Jews the “Devils”. Create campaigns against Jews and make plots against Jews. Every new act or speech of violence against the Jews further detracts credibility of the validity of their religion.
|
God did not change his original nation that he chose for another nation. The nation he chose is the same nation forever.
|
God says in the scriptures and the Torah that the people of Israel are his chosen nation forever. “Six days you shall work and on the seventh day it is a holy day of rest to Hashem“ anyone who shall do work on the Shabbat day will …. And the children of Israel observed the Shabbat “to do the Shabbat throughout the generations – between Me (Hashem) and the children of Israel “ it is a sign forever. (Shemot 31:16-17) (Devarim/ Deut. 5:25)
|
God changes his mind. They disregard these verses.
|
Follow the laws of the 5 books of Moses
|
Follow the laws of the 5 books of Moses to the most minute detail. Know all the details of the laws.
|
Those religions that claim their people to be the “replacement” of the Jewish people “ Do not even know the details of most of the commandments. They act contrary to the commandments. G-d said the seventh day of the week should be the Sabbath Day. The Jewish people observe the Sabbath on the Seventh day “others on the 6th day of the week and others on the first day of the week. This goes against an explicit law in the Torah. There are many more examples too numerous to list.
|
Follow the 10 commandments
|
Follow the 10 commandments with all the details.
|
“You shall not make an image of G-d that is from earth, the skies or the waters” – Those that worship – a man – a man is from earth“ thus it is forbidden from the 10 commandments to worship a man or treat any man as a representation of G-d. A cow is from earth, a tree is from earth“ all are forbidden to treat as images of G-d.
“Thou shalt not kill.” Many pogroms, killings done in the name of the religion.
“Thou shalt not steal” after the pogroms sanctioned by religions they stole goods that belonged to innocent people that they killed.
|
Observant Orthodox Jews are the only ones that consistently observe the laws of the 5 Books of Moses – eaning that we are the True representatives of the Torah.
|
Jews: Observe Passover, wear Tephillin, Observe the Sabbath on the Seventh day, eat Matzah, take the Lulav and Etrog, live in Booths, Celebrate the receiving of the Torah.
|
No other people observe the commandments of the Torah in their entirety and detail like the Orthodox Jews.
|
Philosophers admitted to the Truth of the Torah over their own Philosophy.
|
Aristotle wrote a letter to Alexander the Great at the end of his life testifying that he erred with his philosophy, he regretted teaching it and that he admitted to the Truth of the Torah. (see Meam Loez “ Parasha Yitro)
|
|
Do not present an insult to G-d
|
Jews Praise G-d for his Greatness every day. Believe that G-d is exactly they way that He is described in the Torah according to the RAMBAM. He is not physical, nor spiritual. He is all powerful. He has no weaknesses.
|
Present an insult to G-d. Say G-d is a man or a stone or a tree or a statue “who is limited and nothing in comparison to Hash-m. This is comparable to calling a mighty human king a dog. (See story of Rabbi Akiva)
|
Facts of science correspond to facts written in texts of the religion
|
Because Hash-m created the Torah and then created the world using the Torah as a blueprint facts about the world and nature must correspond to facts that are accepted in the Torah. For instance:
Torah states world is a sphere. World is a sphere.
Torah states Gestation period of a snake is 7 years. Gestation period of a snake is 7 years.
Torah states exactly how many stars in the Universe in Talmud Berachot. Current scientific calculations of number of stars corresponds to number of stars written in the Torah.
Time it takes for moon to revolve around the earth. Time stated by Torah (in Talmud) thousands of years ago corresponds exactly to time determined recently by NASA scientists.
|
There was a point in time which religions stated the world is flat. If they represent G-d, they should know a basic thing like that the world is not flat. Religions are historically against science.
|
People are Chosen People as it states in the Torah
|
Hash-m Chooses the Jewish nation to be a light to the world“ in terms of ethics and serving Hash-m. As it states in the Torah about the Jewish People “For you are a Holy nation to Hash-m Your G-d: You Hash-m your G-d chose to be a special nation to Him “ among all the nations of the world that are on the face of the Earth.” (Deuteronomy 7:6)
|
Others religions say “Jews are devils, are the cause of the worlds problems, are the enemy” and cause Jews tremendous suffering in the name of the religion. Anti-semitism is prevalent.
(Asides the fact that it is strictly forbidden for a Jewish person to marry a gentile – this is one reason why even a totally assimilated Jew should not marry a gentile unless the gentile converts. Judaism doesn’t condone the killing of gentiles. Other religions historically and some currently condone and encourage the killing of Jews. Basically a person who associates themselves with a religion accepts their practices “ currently and historically.
So the Jewish partner should say to the non-Jewish partner “If you love me“ you wouldn’t want me to be killed. If you adhere to a religion“ that shows that you agree with that religion and their past and present practices. Your religion condones the killing of Jews “ and I am Jewish. If you actually love me show me through your action by abandoning your faith and become a sincere convert according to the Torah with a competent orthodox Jewish Rabbi.” If they convert this is a sign that they love you. If they do not accept to convert they surely do not love you. A person who loves another does not want any harm to come to the partner and even more they do not the death of the partner.
Gentiles have two possible paths to choose from in Judaism. To become a Righteous Gentile by following the seven Noahide laws proscribed by the Torah commandments and would not be able to marry a Jew. Or become a full-fledged convert to Torah Judaism by following the program proscribed by a competent Orthodox Jewish Rabbi. (Those already intermarried should contact a competent Orthodox Rabbi to seek guidance for Jewish Conversion).
|
Philosophies are logical
|
Solid logic applies to foundations, all law and all thoughts
|
Can an animal, man dead or alive, or a statue make a house from nothing (ex-nihlo) even more so the entire universe
|
The forefathers and Jewish people are the major subject of the Torah (Tanach “ Torah, Neviim / Prophets and Ketuvim / Writings)
|
Jewish nation occupies major part of the Torah
|
Ishmael is mentioned only briefly. Other guy is not mentioned even once. Ever heard of a novel where the main character is never mentioned once?
|
Law is Standard
|
There is only one version of the Torah “ the five books of Moses, Prophets and Writings. There is no difference between Torah of now and of three thousand years ago. Text of the Torah is standard where found geographically throughout the world, throughout various customs, throughout time.
|
Hundreds or thousands of different versions of their “bible”.
|
Witnessed by millions / Remembered by millions
|
An event of the magnitude of millions of people leaving a country accompanied by clouds and by miraculous events to an entire nation is an national unforgettable memory that people remember (see the kuzari principle “ david gottleib”?)
|
|
Reason for the existence of the religion makes sense
|
The reason for the Jewish religion is so that the Jews will serve as an example as the lights to the nations for them to know how to act in a moral and ethical manner and to become close to Hash-m. The Rambam -Maimonides – writes the reason for why Hashem let other religions to develop is because before people were idol worshipers and their religion serves as a transition stage before they recognize the truth of the Torah.
|
|
Is the Oldest and Original Monotheistic Way of life
|
Judaism is the Original and the Oldest Monotheistic religion in the world. The others are offshoots. HaMotzi Mechavero Alav Haraya. If a person is holding an object we can assume that it belongs to him. If someone wants to take it from him the claimant must bring the proof. Judaism originally held the title of the one and only True Monotheistic religion. Other religions came after and wanted to falsely claim that title. Other religions have to bring proof of their authenticity because they are not holding on to the title. Rather than Judaism having to prove its authenticity.
|
Others are unfaithful imitations of the original.
|
Adam, Noah, Shem, Ever, The Forefathers, Matriarchs, Moses, David, Solomon, observed scrupulously the Torah as it is being observed by observant Jews today
|
The Torah was given to Adam and the Great Men of the Torah who observed it. They observed it in a form similar to the way it is observed today.
|
Other religions weren’t around to be observed by any great people of Bible.
|
The whole world was supposed to observe the Torah – the Seven Noahide Laws – when He gave them to Adam the First Man.
|
|
|